The Mellow Mushroom has been around for many decades serving solid pizza.
It isn't artisan pizza, more a high quality family pizza kind of place. That said they do have a pretty solid fresh fluffy crust, with puffy edges and a light texture.
The atmosphere is bright, clean, with gentle neon lighting vibes.
The service was friendly and when something got messed up with our order they went out of their way to make sure that it was right.
They didn't have a huge variety of toppings, but it also isn't the kind of place that only has mushrooms, green peppers, and onions. They had garlic roasted red peppers, pineapple, artichoke hearts, Kalamata olives, and a handful of other interesting toppings.
The Strawberry Lemon-Limeaid was tasty, although way too sugary for an adult pallet until a good chunk of the ice melted into it. It apparently is made with fresh real strawberry and actually tasted like real citrus.
A good place for basic pizza with picky family members.
King Charles
-
January 30, 2025
Stopped by here after the STL Ren Faire this past
weekend and this was our 3rd experience with Mellow Mushroom and again they did not disappoint. We have tried all 3 locations in the area and each of them were incredible experiences. The food was absolutely delicious. This time we got the Great White and the 50th Anniversary Pizza (Maui Wowie) and they were both soooo good. The roasted tomatoes and garlic on the Great White were soo good. The Maui Wowie pizza was phenomenal!! I highly recommend checking out a Mellow Mushroom if you have not had the pleasure of experiencing their tasty pizzas.
Steve Kaikkonen
-
September 17, 2024
Restaurant was clean and was a good atmosphere. I ordered Buffalo Chicken pizza and Meaty pizza which were both very good. Wife had a cheeseburger and spud puppies (tater tots). All in all everything was great just a little on the expensive side.
Matt
-
December 07, 2024
Very good service. Like that we could split pizza toppings. Lots of specialty style pizzas to choose from besides creating your own. Nice and generous and on the cheese and toppings.
Patricia Frasca
-
November 09, 2024
Was in on a Friday evening. The person seating us could not have been more nice or efficient (and it was her first shift). Our waitress was very nice and did not keep us waiting to place drink and food orders. The food was very good, had the Great White pizza. The restaurant was very clean! The owner made her rounds speaking with customers. It was an overall great experience. Will definitely return and recommend it to family and friends.
Our Address
4716 Mid Rivers Mall Dr, Cottleville, MO 63376, USA
The Mellow Mushroom has been around for many decades serving solid pizza. It isn't artisan pizza, more a high quality family pizza kind of place. That said they do have a pretty solid fresh fluffy crust, with puffy edges and a light texture. The atmosphere is bright, clean, with gentle neon lighting vibes. The service was friendly and when something got messed up with our order they went out of their way to make sure that it was right. They didn't have a huge variety of toppings, but it also isn't the kind of place that only has mushrooms, green peppers, and onions. They had garlic roasted red peppers, pineapple, artichoke hearts, Kalamata olives, and a handful of other interesting toppings. The Strawberry Lemon-Limeaid was tasty, although way too sugary for an adult pallet until a good chunk of the ice melted into it. It apparently is made with fresh real strawberry and actually tasted like real citrus. A good place for basic pizza with picky family members.
Stopped by here after the STL Ren Faire this past weekend and this was our 3rd experience with Mellow Mushroom and again they did not disappoint. We have tried all 3 locations in the area and each of them were incredible experiences. The food was absolutely delicious. This time we got the Great White and the 50th Anniversary Pizza (Maui Wowie) and they were both soooo good. The roasted tomatoes and garlic on the Great White were soo good. The Maui Wowie pizza was phenomenal!! I highly recommend checking out a Mellow Mushroom if you have not had the pleasure of experiencing their tasty pizzas.
Restaurant was clean and was a good atmosphere. I ordered Buffalo Chicken pizza and Meaty pizza which were both very good. Wife had a cheeseburger and spud puppies (tater tots). All in all everything was great just a little on the expensive side.
Very good service. Like that we could split pizza toppings. Lots of specialty style pizzas to choose from besides creating your own. Nice and generous and on the cheese and toppings.
Was in on a Friday evening. The person seating us could not have been more nice or efficient (and it was her first shift). Our waitress was very nice and did not keep us waiting to place drink and food orders. The food was very good, had the Great White pizza. The restaurant was very clean! The owner made her rounds speaking with customers. It was an overall great experience. Will definitely return and recommend it to family and friends.